Earlier this year, we purchased a Pizza Passport for the low cost of $35. With the passport in hand, we were able to explore the region and receive 50% off a pizza of any size and toppings combination from over 40 participating pizza locations.
And we did exactly that. Over the course of the last 6 months or so, we’ve dined in twenty different pizza places all over the STL: some good, some not so good, some incredibly good, some thin crust, some thick, some mozzarella, some that all too familiar eclectic mix of Swiss, Provolone, Cheddar, Liquid Smoke, and a plethora of preservatives and emulsifiers that technically (at least according to the FDA) classify it not as cheese per se, but rather as “Processed Cheese Product.” Oh well, at least it has the word cheese in the name, right? And if I’m being honest, I wouldn’t care if they discovered plutonium in Provel. I’m still going to eat it. It’s delicious.
Keep in mind, I visited each and every one of these restaurants exactly one time and therefore am evaluating them based on a sole experience. An experience that usually consisted of a basic one topping pepperoni, because you can’t exactly compare supreme pizza from one place with buffalo chicken from another. I suppose some of these experiences could be chalked up as anomalies. Perhaps they were understaffed on the day I arrived and prepared my pizza in haste. Maybe the crust didn’t proof properly, or the sauce didn’t blend right, or perhaps the dishwasher brought in some really potent weed and they all had trouble focusing for a while. Nevertheless, here are my reviews. I’ve indexed these in Drake order so we’ll be starting from the bottom.
20.
GOOD NEWS BREWING (O FALLON)
Nothing but bad news here. Good News serves up 9” pizzas (think the size of a normal paper plate) with a thin, undercooked crust, topped with dry sauce, and bland toppings. At $15 a pop, even with a half-off discount, it seems criminally overpriced. If I had to say a nice thing about them… the beer was good.
Outdoor seating.
18.
SCHOTTZIE’S (SOUTH COUNTY)
Schottzie’s is an ordinary bar with ordinary food. The only thing extraordinary about this place is the incompetence of the staff. It took our waitress 15 minutes to bring us our waters. She also forgot to submit half of our order and only after finally dropping off our pizza, did she realize that she had never given us plates or silverware. “Oops,” she said lackadaisically. She then moseyed to the server station, a mere six feet away from us, proceeded to pull out a bag of Jalapeño Crunchy Cheetos from behind the computer and deposited two huge handfuls into her fat mouth, before grabbing a stack of plates with her gross, disgusting Cheeto fingers and carelessly tossing the plates on our table. This. Chick. Was. The. Worst.
But enough about that. This isn’t about the service. It’s about the quality of the pizza and the quality was low. I’m not sure if they were using a Provel/Mozzarella blend or what they were using but the cheese tasted a little strange. It tasted like one of those times when you pull a Jack’s frozen pizza out of the freezer late at night, usually while drunk, and decide that there’s not enough cheese on it so you pull whatever shredded cheese you happen to have in the fridge and layer it on top, only to find out fifteen minutes later that your additions made no improvements to the pizza, and if anything it made it worse because the cheese melted inconsistently and now the crust is kind of soggy.
17.
PIO’S (SAINT CHARLES)
A block away from Historic Downtown Saint Charles sits a dilapidated structure in the same spot it’s resided for the last 50 years. If the food were better, you could refer to the state of the building as charming and timeless, but with the mediocre fare they serve, it’s more accurate to label it as antiquated and worn-down. The sauce is stale and the cheese is flavorless; it’s an all-around lackluster pizza. I didn’t even finish the leftovers.
17.
SAUCY’S (HIGH RIDGE)
If you were to take the sauce and crust from Domino’s, layer it with cheese from Little Caesar’s, and drizzle garlic butter seasoning from Papa John’s on top, you will have successfully constructed a pie from Saucy’s Pizzeria. Nothing special, really. It’s the kind of pizza that serves its purpose but fails to leave a lasting impression. Good, not great. Adequate, yet appetizing. Filling, yet forgettable. Which really speaks as a testament to the preeminence of pizza because even when it’s just okay, it’s better than most other meals. So, if you’re in High Ridge and have a hankering for pizza, stop by Saucy’s, or don’t. I don’t care what you do.
16.
NANCY’S (O FALLON)
Nancy’s serves up a flaky deep dish crust topped with mozzarella and layers of toppings which are then doused in roughly one and a half to two gallons of marinara sauce, and it is at this point that it ceases being pizza and morphs into some sort of lasagna with pepperoni. It is my assertion that pizza is not meant to be eaten with a knife and fork, and if you find yourself needing the aid of utensils to eat one, something must have gone horribly wrong during the baking process. I’d rate this place lower but it would be unfair. After all, they specialize in authentic Chicago style pizza and by all accounts, they’ve delivered on that promise. It just so happens to not be my cup of tea. I prefer actual pizza, not whatever this was supposed to be.
*Carryout only
15.
RED OVEN WOOD FIRED PIZZA (FLORISSANT)
Situated in the heart of downtown Florissant in a refurbished two story brick building is Red Oven Pizzeria. An immaculately clean, well-decorated, and elegant restaurant that at first, appeared to be operated exclusively by an 11-year-old boy. After about twenty minutes or so of exchanging looks of concern and befuddlement with the other guests in the dining room, the owner emerged from the kitchen to assist with taking orders, and delivering drinks, thus sparing me from making the difficult decision between choosing to call Child Protective Services or IMO’s.
Red Oven’s mission is to serve authentic Neapolitan pizza and since I’ve never been to Naples, I’m just going to have to take their word for it. The wood fired oven cast a light char on a chewy crust, coated with a tangy and flavorful sauce. The pizzas are offered in one size (12”) only, so we ordered two. My wife’s Margherita was bland and underwhelming. My pepperoni was better. But both seemed light on cheese, and neither one was hot when delivered to our table. They were warm but not hot, and the only thing worse than waiting 35 minutes for a meal is waiting 35 minutes for a meal that isn’t even fresh.
Clearly we caught them on an off night and if we lived closer, I’d be willing to give them a second chance because we were looking forward to this place and it was a bit of a letdown. My expectations were higher.
14.
PIZZA WORLD (CREVE COUER)
This is a very greasy pizza. I’d rate it one notch, maybe a notch and a half above Costco Pizza. It’s definitely more flavorful and topped with savory seasonings. Also, they have a pizza challenge. If you and a friend can eat a 24” inch pizza in a half hour, you can win a free T-shirt. So, if you have a ravenous appetite and a desperate need for a free T-shirt… this is your place.
13.
MONTE BELLO (LEMAY TOWNSHIP)
Tucked away on a tiny corner in Lemay Township rests the charming and timeless Monte Bello pizzeria. At first glance, it appears to be an abandoned residence. A suspicion that’s eerily confirmed with a quick peek through the window. But as you bravely push through your fears of being murdered and descend the staircase into the dimly lit basement below, the aromas from the kitchen waft upwards, and tendrils of freshly cooked dough and vibrant marinara seep into your nostrils, giving the nerve endings in your nose a gentle little hug.
You reach the bottom to an array of tables clustered together so closely it’s difficult to get in and out of your seat. Try your hardest not to be tall when you visit as the ceilings are quite low. Yes, you could describe the accommodations as a little cramped, at least before you try the food that is, after the fact, you’ll realize that the word you were looking for instead was, “Cozy”.
The oldest existing pizzeria in Saint Louis, established in 1950, it practically predates the invention of Provel, not that they use it anyway. Monte Bello uses a 4-cheese blend complemented by a robust spice mixture that’s been a family secret for half a century. My one qualm with the quality is the abundance of cornmeal stuck to the bottom of an otherwise delicious crust. This place is extremely busy and the kitchen is still operating with the original oven that was installed in the fifties so the pizzas take a little longer to cook. Reservations aren’t required but are recommended and even with one, you’ll still probably have to wait a while.
12.
LILIANA’S (COTTLEVILLE)
We were unable to make it to the OG Liliana’s off Tesson Ferry but did manage to visit their second location in Cottleville, which is in a building that is much bigger than it needs to be. It used to be a Mexican restaurant, and then after that it was something else. Then it was vacant for several years, or it was either a Crossfit gym or a church? No one really knows for sure what this place was between 2019 - 2023, but now it is Liliana’s. Having said all this, the pizza was pretty tasty, with the lone exception of the mounds of cornmeal stuck to the bottom of the crust that you already know displeases me. I’d rate this place to be about on par with Stefanina’s—the clear-cut best of the three major STL style chains. If you know, you know. Translation for the youngsters, IYKYK. In other words, if Cecil Whittakers is Jay Leno and IMO’s is David Letterman, then Stefanina’s is Conan O’Brien. Translation for the youngsters, if Seth Meyers is Cecil Whittakers and Jimmy Fallon is IMO’s, then Stefanina’s is Conan O’Brien.
11.
Mama Mel’s (Lemay)
This place presented us with quite the quandary as they offer both STL and Detroit-style pizza. Not wanting to make the wrong decision, we went with one of each. The Detroit-style wasn’t the best. Frankly, it seems like the thicker the crust, the less likely I am to enjoy it, and Detroit Pizza is as thick as it comes. The STL was much better. The sauce was tangy. The cheese was just the right amount of burnt, and the crust was nice and crispy.
10.
MONICAL’S (O Fallon)
Pasted on a glass window of this O Fallon storefront are big, bold white letters that read, “Voted best pizza in St.Louis” And while I don’t think that’s true at all, it is quite tasty. Perhaps a more accurate statement would be to say, “Best pizza in this particular strip mall” or “Second best pizza on Highway K” (Ami’s). But I digress. Monical’s has a spacious dining room with a full bar, extensive menu, and several specialty pizzas, including “The Point.”
The Point sports a sweeter sauce with extra toppings. It’s also shaped like a triangle. Is it gimmicky? Yes. Is it delicious? Also, yes.
9.
That’sa Nice’a Pizza (South County)
This aptly named storefront in Concord offers a crunchy thin crust with a fiercely sweet sauce that pairs perfectly with mozzarella cheese. Provel is available upon request but isn’t as agreeable to the sauce, so go with the mozzarella. Trust me on this.
*Carryout only
8.
HOT PIZZA COLD BEER (SAINT LOUIS)
Brought to you by the same innovative minds behind Sugarfire Smokehouse and Hi-Point Drive-in comes a fresh new eatery off Washington Ave that will indulge your taste buds’ two most primal desires. Hot Pizza, Cold Beer, sounds like a dream and delivers as promised. With its crispy crust and zesty sauce, each enormous New York slice sends bursts of dopamine surging through your system, bite after mouthwatering bite
*Metered street parking
7.
DOUBLE D’S PIZZERIA (SOUTH COUNTY)
First, work up an appetite, browsing for treasure at the South County antique mall, then head next door to a pizzeria that will satisfy your hunger and titillate your taste buds. Double D’s boasts loads of flavorful cheese layered atop a zesty sauce covered with delicious peppery seasonings. The one downside was that the crust was a little on the doughier side, but altogether it was still a fabulous pizza.
6.
NICK AND ELENA’S (BRECKINRIDGE HILLS)
If you want Provel in its purest form, take a trip down to Breckinridge Hills and visit Nick and Elena’s, where the cheese sports an orangish hue and each bite delivers a spicy kick. This is quintessential Saint Louis-style pizza. The type of pie that would make a New Yorker so angry he’d chuck the box at an oncoming taxi. With its crispy cracker crust, piquant sauce, and perfectly melted cheese, it’s a masterpiece in culinary achievement. I’d say it’s on par or perhaps a notch above Pirrone’s pizza, which, prior to this passport endeavor, I considered to be the best pizza in town.
5.
NUBBY’S (OAKVILLE)
I normally stray away from comparing food to sex, but with Nubby’s, I’m willing to make an exception. The moment you enter the front door, the sweet, smoky aroma sends shivers down your spine and stimulates your most tender senses. All that meat being pulled in the kitchen is likely to put you in the mood to masticate, and you won’t even care who sees. For a place known for its BBQ, Nubby’s has no business baking a pizza this damn delicious. They offer both a hand-tossed and a STL style thin crust. We ordered the thin crust, and it hit like a vintage Mike Tyson knockout punch. I have no doubt that the hand-tossed slaps as well.
With several big screen TV’s, Nubby’s seems like a good place to watch sports, but you’re not going to care about the game. No, the only thing you’ll be focusing on is the feeling of pure bliss as you sink your teeth into each savory slice. So, stuff your guts, get your fill, and leave yearning for more.
4.
CAFE PIAZZA (SAINT LOUIS)
Directly across the street from the Anheuser-Busch brewery is a resplendent little hole in the wall that will curtail your hunger and cure your blues. Leave your troubles behind as you enter the threshold of Café Piazza; grab a seat and immerse yourself in its aura of nonchalance. This whole place is a vibe. The interior is visually striking. An intricate mural sprawls across the ceiling. Various paintings adorn the walls. But the real work of art… The real masterpiece… is what’s cooking in the kitchen!
The canvas, an impeccable hand-tossed crust, baked to crisp perfection, covered with brushstrokes of tantalizingly bold tomato sauce, and splattered with fresh mozzarella and robust seasonings.
This pizza’s beauty knows no boundaries. It belongs on the covers of magazines. Slap a pair of denim jeans on a pie from Café Piazza, and American Eagle will forget Sydney Sweeney ever existed. Each mouthwatering bite whips your taste buds into a frenzy like a group of preteen girls at a Taylor Swift concert. Once you’re finished, venture into the arcade behind the bar and play one of the twenty or so pinball machines on site and leave with an equally satisfied stomach and soul.
*Street parking only
3.
UNCLE LEO’S (CONCORD)
Another South County gem that lives up to the hype. This is a magnificent pizza and one of the best STL style I’ve ever had. The ingredients work together all too well. It’s more than a partnership. It’s a divine union. A glorious harmonization of flavors. An irresistible arrangement of thick pepperonis blanketed in layers of gooey Provel, complemented by an expertly seasoned savory sauce. It’s the kind of pizza you can’t stop eating. You just keep telling yourself, “One more slice… One more slice…” and the next thing you know, you’re staring at an empty box with a couple of balled-up napkins and a desperate need for a bottle of Tums. It’s worth it though. Trust me. The indigestion won’t be enough to wipe the satisfying grin off your face.
*No dining room; a few outdoor tables. Otherwise, carryout only.
2.
AFFTON PIZZA COMPANY (AFFTON)
On the corner of a small strip mall off Reavis Barracks Road sits what is perhaps the most slept-on pizza place in Saint Louis County. We arrived on a Saturday evening, much to our surprise, to a completely empty dining room. That’s okay, we thought. More food for us. They are evidently known for their garlic breads, but we opted instead for chicken tenders, fries, and mozzarella sticks the size of hot dogs. I was almost ready to tap out until the pizza arrived. My heart nearly skipped a beat as my gaze surveyed its majestic beauty. It was covered head to toe in juicy pepperonis generously piled high, captivating me with its alluring aroma. Steam steadily rose from the hot, gooey cheese, leaving me as enchanted as a cartoon wolf in the presence of a hot lady. “Awooooo!” I unleashed a primitive howl. My jaw dropped to the floor, and my tongue rolled out of my mouth the entire length of the table while my eyes briefly transformed into slot machines, landing on ❤️❤️, which then popped out of my head to absurd dimensions. Suddenly, a train whistle magically appeared at the table. I pulled it, and a horn blared while steam began pouring out of my ears. I started to levitate in the air, unable to resist the urge to pound my fists on the table, rattling all the plates and cups. I tried to compose myself but had no control over my vocal cords. I just floated there midair, muttering, “Hummina Hummina, Hummina, Hummina!” at a comically fast pace. After a few awkward moments, I regained control of my senses, my tongue and eyes fell back to their original proportions, and gravity returned, settling me back into my chair. “Well, that was weird.” I remarked to my wife and child, who were both staring at me with their usual looks of embarrassment and disapproval. To sum things up, Affton Pizza Company is very, very good!
1.
BUD’S PIZZA AND BEER (SAINT LOUIS)
Buds serves exquisite New York Style pizza with wide, sturdy slices of flavorful cheese, delectable sauce, and crispy pepperonis that curl up on the edges. We ordered a full pizza because of the passport, but they also sell by the slice and have great happy hour and beer specials throughout the day. I’m telling you this pizza was flawless. It looked so good it could have started a 10-year war. The “Helen of Troy” of pizzas.
I just can’t say enough nice things about this restaurant. The aesthetic is on point: the red plush leather booths, the vintage Budweiser signs, even the music they played while we were there seemed like it was handpicked to complement my tastes. Like the entire place was built specifically for me. I took one final swig of my $3 Bud Light draft and leaned back in my seat, shifting my gaze from side to side trying to soak in the electric ambience. Bearing an expression of wide-eyed astonishment, I perhaps mimicked the countenance of the late, great Ray Liotta when he portrayed Shoeless Joe Jackson visiting Ray Kinsella’s farm for the first time in the iconic movie, “Field of Dreams.”
“Is this heaven?” I startled, suddenly aware of the fact that I had just spoken out loud.
“No,” our server replied jovially. “It’s Buds. Can I get you another beer?”
No parking lot.
Metered parking only.